<?xml version="1.0"?>
<!--<!DOCTYPE nitf SYSTEM "nitf-3-4.dtd">-->
<nitf>
  <head>
    <title id="Title">#Title</title>
    <docdata management-doc-idref="">
      <date.issue id="CreationDate" norm="" />
      <du-key id="rev-ver" generation="1" version="Default" />
      <du-key id="Parent-Version" version="" />
      <identified-content>
        <classifier id="newspro-nitf" value="r2" />
        <classifier id="Newspro-App" value="Epaper" />
        <classifier id="Content-Type" value="Story" />
        <classifier id="storyID" value="431112" />
        <classifier id="CmsConID" value="" />
        <classifier id="Desk" value="" />
        <classifier id="Source" value="" />
        <classifier id="Edition" value="" />
        <classifier id="Category" value="-1" />
        <classifier id="UserName" value="" />
        <classifier id="PublicationDate" value="18/10/2026" />
        <classifier id="PublicationName" value="DailyStar" />
        <classifier id="IsPublished" value="Y" />
        <classifier id="IsPlaced" value="Y" />
        <classifier id="IsCompleated" value="N" />
        <classifier id="IsProofed" value="N" />
        <classifier id="User" value="" />
        <classifier id="Headline-Count" value="" />
        <classifier id="Slug-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Photo-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Caption-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Word-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Character-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Location" value="" />
        <classifier id="TemplateType" value="1" />
        <classifier id="StoryType" value="Story" />
        <classifier id="Author" value="" />
        <classifier id="UOM" value="mm" />
        <classifier id="kicker" value="" />
        <classifier id="ByLine" value="" />
        <classifier id="DateLine" value="" />
        <classifier id="box-geometry" value="285,108,972,1025" />
         <classifier id="Layer" value="Layer 1"/>
          <classifier id="numcol" value="4"/>
         <classifier id="ArticleStyle" value=""/>
       <classifier id="Epaper-Build" value="7.1.5.2"/>
  <classifier id="ProcessingDateTime" value="Sat Oct 17 2026 20:42:11 GMT+0600"/>
      </identified-content>

      <urgency id="home-page" ed-urg="0" />
      <urgency id="priority" ed-urg="0" />
      <doc-scope id="scope" value="0" />
    </docdata>
    <pubdata type="print" name="DailyStar" date.publication="20261018T000000+5.30" edition.name="Dhaka Edition" edition.area="MAI" position.section="DST18102606MAI-EDITORIAL" position.sequence="6" ex-ref="DST18102606MAI-EDITORIAL.indd" />
  </head>
  <body boxBorderWeightColor="" boxBorderWeight="">
<body.head>
      <hedline>
    	<hl2 id="Headline1" ul="0" ol="0" ulColor=""  ulWeight=""  olColor=""  olWeight="" textFrameColor="" orgstyle="[No Paragraph Style]" class="1" MainHead="#isMainHead2" style="Headline2">
		<lang class="3" colour="#000000" orgstyle="[No Paragraph Style]" style="Headline2"  font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Heavy" size="45">Two executions and the limits of diplomatic friendship</lang>
	</hl2>

       </hedline>
</body.head>
    <body.content id="Bodytext" CaptionAsBody="0">
     <block>
	<media id="1" media-type="image">
		<media-reference id="tn" source-credit="" data-location="1" source="ImageOfFrame38802_6_MAI_tn.jpg"  Units="pixels" width="50" height="50"></media-reference>
<media-reference id="tn" source-credit="" data-location="1" source="ImageOfGroup42759_6_MAI_tn.jpg"  Units="pixels" width="50" height="50"></media-reference>
<media-reference id="tn" source-credit="" data-location="3" source="0ab0Khan_Khalid_6_MAI_tn.jpg"  Units="pixels" width="50" height="50"></media-reference>
<media-reference id="tn" source-credit="" data-location="4" source="3a1ced_1_SAUDI__6_MAI_tn.jpg"  Units="pixels" width="50" height="50"></media-reference>
	</media>
</block>

     <p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">A friendship between two states means little if one discovers through the news media that the other has executed its citizens. On October 14, Saudi Arabia executed two people it identified as Bangladeshi nationals for an “immoral act” inside a mosque in Makkah. Bangladesh’s Consulate General in Jeddah has confirmed that it received no advance notification. The question here is not simply whether diplomatic courtesy was neglected. It is whether safeguards that could have mattered while the two were alive were ever available.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">The publicly reported Saudi statement leaves the precise offence undisclosed. It describes a discretionary death sentence under ta’zir, subsequently approved for implementation. That account does not permit a reliable assessment of the evidence or the offence’s gravity. Neither does invoking the sanctity of the place explain why death was justified. The official account also omits basic details about the proceedings: when the two were arrested, how long they remained in custody, whether they had legal representation and whether their families were informed. Without these details, it is impossible to assess whether the defendants had a meaningful opportunity to challenge the charges and sentences.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">According to a report published by </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">The Daily Star</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9"> on October 17, Bangladesh was still awaiting a formal Saudi response to its note verbale seeking confirmation of the executions and verification of the individuals’ identities and nationality. These uncertainties require investigation, not speculation. But a government identifying the executed as foreigners should be able to explain how their consular rights were protected.  
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9"> Saudi Arabia has jurisdiction over offences committed within its territory, but this does not make its treatment of defendants exclusively a domestic matter. Sovereignty includes obligations voluntarily accepted through treaties. Bangladesh need not claim a veto over Saudi judgments to insist that those obligations be respected. Both countries are parties to the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. Article 36 of the convention requires authorities to inform detained foreigners of their consular rights without delay. If a detainee requests it, the relevant consulate must also be notified without delay. Consular officers are entitled to visit and communicate with their nationals in detention and arrange for legal representation, unless the detainee expressly opposes such assistance. The obligation to explain these rights does not depend on the detainee already knowing enough to ask.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Legal precision matters here. Article 36 does not expressly impose an unconditional requirement to notify the foreign government before every execution. Article 37(a), however, separately requires consular notification of a foreign national’s death when the authorities have the relevant information. The immediate questions, therefore, are whether the two were informed of their consular rights, whether they requested consular assistance, whether access was obstructed, and whether notification followed the deaths. The absence of advance notice alone does not answer all these questions.  
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9"> These are not administrative technicalities. In the case Avena and Other Mexican Nationals, the International Court of Justice required the United States to provide effective review and reconsideration of convictions and sentences, taking account of consular violations and possible prejudice. Its reasoning demonstrates why consular protection belongs within the administration of justice, not outside it as diplomatic decoration. Execution without an effective opportunity for such review forecloses the possibility of correcting a conviction during the defendant’s lifetime.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">The proportionality question is equally serious. Saudi Arabia ratified the Arab Charter on Human Rights in 2009. Article 6 of the charter restricts capital punishment to the ‘most serious crimes’ and recognises the right to seek pardon or commutation. Article 16 protects access to counsel, interpreters, adequate defence preparation and appeal. Were these protections effective in practice? A statement announcing final approval cannot answer that question. These are commitments Saudi Arabia itself accepted, not standards Bangladesh would be inventing after the event.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">The UN Human Rights Committee interprets “most serious crimes” as crimes of extreme gravity involving intentional killing (General Comment 36, p. 8, paragraph 35). Saudi Arabia is not a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which the committee was interpreting, so that interpretation cannot simply be presented as its treaty obligation. It remains an important benchmark, while the Arab Charter supplies an independent legal restraint. Nothing in the published account of Saudi Arabia identifies an intentional killing, so the authorities should explain how the offence in question satisfied the exceptional threshold for taking two lives.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Advance warning also has an international foundation beyond consular law. Human Rights Council resolution 30/5 calls for adequate advance information about executions for prisoners, their families, and legal representatives (p. 3, paragraph 4). This is not a binding treaty requirement to notify another government. It is, however, a clear standard against leaving those most affected to discover an execution afterwards. Whether these families received such information must be established.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Bangladesh should also examine its own consistency. Both Dhaka and Riyadh voted against that resolution in 2015. A vote against the whole text does not establish opposition to every safeguard it contains. Nevertheless, protections for people facing execution should not become important only when our own nationals need them.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Our bilateral relationship makes these questions harder to evade. Bangladesh sent more than 750,000 workers to Saudi Arabia in 2025. Pilgrimage sustains another substantial connection between the two countries. These ties should strengthen expectations of reliable consular cooperation. This is not to suggest that Bangladesh’s nationals deserve special treatment because of their religious connection or because their labour benefits Saudi Arabia, which would make it sound like a reward or entitlement. But nothing justifies the withholding of established rights or safeguards either. 
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9"> Dhaka, therefore, should seek verified identities, judgments, dates of arrest and detention, and records of access to legal representation and interpretation. It should explain its findings to the families and disclose any institutional failures without compromising private information. Its own mission’s conduct also requires review, without assuming negligence where officials genuinely lacked notice. Where violations are established, Bangladesh should pursue accountability and appropriate reparation.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">For future cases, Bangladesh should negotiate a protocol requiring timely consular notification, subject to the detainee’s wishes, and advance execution notice, backed by funded legal assistance and systematic monitoring of capital cases. Pending that, it should seek stays in other capital cases where access and defence safeguards remain unverified.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">A diplomatic protest after an execution cannot restore the opportunity to contest a charge, challenge a sentence, or say goodbye. The measure of a bilateral relationship is not how warmly the governments describe each other, but whether their cooperation protects people before protection becomes impossible.</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="[No Paragraph Style]">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#231f20" orgstyle="[No Paragraph Style]" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Heavy" size="12">Saudi Arabia ratified the Arab Charter on Human Rights in 2009. Article 6 of the charter restricts capital punishment to the ‘most serious crimes’ and recognises the right to seek pardon or commutation. Article 16 protects access to counsel, interpreters, adequate defence preparation and appeal. Were these protections effective in practice? A statement announcing final approval cannot answer that question. These are commitments Saudi Arabia itself accepted, not standards Bangladesh would be inventing after the event.</lang>
</p>

    </body.content>
  </body>
</nitf>