<?xml version="1.0"?>
<!--<!DOCTYPE nitf SYSTEM "nitf-3-4.dtd">-->
<nitf>
  <head>
    <title id="Title">#Title</title>
    <docdata management-doc-idref="">
      <date.issue id="CreationDate" norm="" />
      <du-key id="rev-ver" generation="1" version="Default" />
      <du-key id="Parent-Version" version="" />
      <identified-content>
        <classifier id="newspro-nitf" value="r2" />
        <classifier id="Newspro-App" value="Epaper" />
        <classifier id="Content-Type" value="Story" />
        <classifier id="storyID" value="430290" />
        <classifier id="CmsConID" value="" />
        <classifier id="Desk" value="" />
        <classifier id="Source" value="" />
        <classifier id="Edition" value="" />
        <classifier id="Category" value="-1" />
        <classifier id="UserName" value="" />
        <classifier id="PublicationDate" value="15/10/2026" />
        <classifier id="PublicationName" value="DailyStar" />
        <classifier id="IsPublished" value="Y" />
        <classifier id="IsPlaced" value="Y" />
        <classifier id="IsCompleated" value="N" />
        <classifier id="IsProofed" value="N" />
        <classifier id="User" value="" />
        <classifier id="Headline-Count" value="" />
        <classifier id="Slug-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Photo-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Caption-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Word-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Character-Count" value="0" />
        <classifier id="Location" value="" />
        <classifier id="TemplateType" value="1" />
        <classifier id="StoryType" value="Story" />
        <classifier id="Author" value="" />
        <classifier id="UOM" value="mm" />
        <classifier id="kicker" value="" />
        <classifier id="ByLine" value="" />
        <classifier id="DateLine" value="" />
        <classifier id="box-geometry" value="35,108,972,843" />
         <classifier id="Layer" value="Layer 1"/>
          <classifier id="numcol" value="6"/>
         <classifier id="ArticleStyle" value=""/>
       <classifier id="Epaper-Build" value="7.1.5.2"/>
  <classifier id="ProcessingDateTime" value="Wed Oct 14 2026 18:33:13 GMT+0600"/>
      </identified-content>

      <urgency id="home-page" ed-urg="0" />
      <urgency id="priority" ed-urg="0" />
      <doc-scope id="scope" value="0" />
    </docdata>
    <pubdata type="print" name="DailyStar" date.publication="20261015T000000+5.30" edition.name="Dhaka Edition" edition.area="MAI" position.section="DST15102610MAI-DS" position.sequence="10" ex-ref="DST15102610MAI-DS.indd" />
  </head>
  <body boxBorderWeightColor="" boxBorderWeight="">
<body.head>
      <hedline>
    	<hl1 id="Headline1" ul="0" ol="0" ulColor=""  ulWeight=""  olColor=""  olWeight="" textFrameColor="" orgstyle="SHOULDER 2025" class="1" MainHead="false" style="Headline1">
		<lang class="3" colour="#000000" orgstyle="SHOULDER 2025" style="Headline1"  font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="16">INTERVIEW </lang>
	</hl1>
<hl2 id="Headline1" ul="0" ol="0" ulColor=""  ulWeight=""  olColor=""  olWeight="" textFrameColor="" orgstyle="HEAD new 40 BLACK" class="1" MainHead="true" style="Headline2">
		<lang class="3" colour="#000000" orgstyle="HEAD new 40 BLACK" style="Headline2"  font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Black" size="55">Remembering Sumit Sarkar, the historian and the iconoclast </lang>
	</hl2>

       </hedline>
</body.head>
    <body.content id="Bodytext" CaptionAsBody="0">
     <block>
	<media id="1" media-type="image">
		<media-reference id="tn" source-credit="" data-location="1" source="ImageOfFrame10496_10_MAI_tn.jpg"  Units="pixels" width="50" height="50"></media-reference>
<media-reference id="tn" source-credit="" data-location="2" source="Illustrations_9_10_MAI_tn.jpg"  Units="pixels" width="50" height="50"></media-reference>
	</media>
</block>

     <p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BY NAME_2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BY NAME_2025" font="Impact" fontStyle="Regular" size="9">▌</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BY NAME_2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">	SUBHORANJAN DASGUPTA
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Slender, small-built and soft-spoken, Sumit Sarkar, who passed away on August 13, was a towering historian, one of the very best we have seen in recent years. Author of classics like </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">The Swadeshi Movement in Bengal 1903–1918</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9"> (1973), </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">Writing Social History </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(1998), and</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9"> Modern Times: India 1880s–1950s: Environment, Economy and Culture </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="INDENTLESS BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(Permanent Black, 2014), he guided generations of researchers and students.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Academic and author Subhoranjan Dasgupta, who knew Sarkar closely, draws on their conversations over the years to explore his views on Hindutva’s reading of history, the discipline of history, his relationship with subaltern historians and his book </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">Modern Times: India 1880s–1950s: Environment, Economy and Culture.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">Why did the then HRD Minister, Murli Manohar Joshi, block the publication of the sixth volume of the </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">Towards Freedom: Documents on the Movement for Independence in India, 1946 (</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">2007) series, a project of the Indian Council of Historical Research, in 2000? You had prepared and edited this volume with meticulous care.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Because it questioned and challenged the Hindutva project of history, theorised first by Veer Savarkar in his pathbreaking</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9"> Hindutva: Who Is a Hindu? </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(1923) and then, more virulently, by Guru Golwalkar in </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">We or Our Nationhood Defined </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(1939). This volume, suppressed by the BJP regime, not only underlined the distance that had existed between the Sangh Parivar and our struggle for freedom (though this unpalatable truth was no longer a secret) but also exposed the close understanding that had bound together the colonial rulers and the Saffron Family. The volume was released in 2004 when the Congress returned to power after winning the election.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">Could you please pinpoint the primary traits of this Hindutva project of history?
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">First, the imposition of the thesis that the Punyabhumi (Holy Land) and Pitribhumi (Fatherland) of Bharat, Savarkar employed these two Sanskrit terms, were reserved for Hindus only. That is, Muslims and Christians were, by birth, aliens and outsiders. Second, the Muslim invaders destroyed the glory, grandeur and harmony of ancient Sanatani Bharat, which embodied the very apex of human civilisation and culture. Third, all possible measures have to be implemented to construct a “Hindu” nation where the main adversaries, Muslims and Christians, will have to survive as second-class citizens. Mohan Bhagwat, the RSS supremo, labelled the project of a “Hindu nation” as “non-negotiable” a few months ago. This carefully charted programme regards history as something narrowly unilinear, exclusionary to the extreme and hostile, nourished as it is by hatred and consequent violence. Hindutvadis seek a return to the age of kings and queens, not to humankind.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">I need to stress that the Hindutva project of history goes all out to justify its aberration by invoking the tempting principle of nationalism. We have to be very careful here. The ‘nationalism’ of the Sangh Parivar is intrinsically different from the other nationalism, which was anti-colonial and anti-imperialist in origin and, moreover, redemptive in essence. It is sustained by the indispensable attachment to and love for the marginalised human being. Gandhi, Nehru and Rabindranath, in particular, wedded this essentially human dimension, not sectarian at all, to our configuration of the nation. Recall Rabindranath’s masterly novel </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">Ghore Baire </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(1916) and his superb essay “Nationalism” in this context. I myself have drawn on their thoughts and placed the human being, united to race, religion or colour, at the very centre of my concern in books like </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">Beyond Nationalist Frames: Postmodernism, Hindu Nationalism, History </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(IU Press, 2002) and in other texts.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">But the genuine study of history and its epistemic nature are nurtured by totally different impulses?
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">Obviously. When we reflect on the real worth of history, we travel beyond these petty religious, racial and even conscripted nationalist frames. We champion many histories, including those of Dalits, subalterns, the environment, gender, art and faith. In other words, we propose a stimulating multitude of narratives instead of a black-and-white, mythical account crafted by Hindutva and chained from all sides.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">You endorsed the history of the subalterns initially, but later opposed it. How would you evaluate this conflict, this drastic change in your attitude?
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">First, I recall the attachment. When I visited Oxford for a year in 1976-77, I interacted with the historians of the Subaltern School, Professor Ranajit Guha in particular, who was reverentially called ‘Pope’ by his associates. My discussions with him at his home in Sussex were really inspiring. In fact, once or twice, we conversed the whole night on the subject of Indian peasantry. He was fascinating. Well, I became one of the founders of the Subaltern Studies Collective.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">But then later, I shall not go into names, some illustrious members categorically criticised the Enlightenment, the nation-state and secularism. Indeed, they came to link this critical trend with uncomfortable assessments which, at times, came perilously close to the worldview of Hindutva. Sadhvi Ritambhara, for instance, was presented as the bearer of ‘subaltern consciousness’.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">As a result, their ‘history from below’ turned out to be markedly different from my ‘history from below’, which I had explored in </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">The Swadeshi Movement in Bengal </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(1973). Here, I endeavoured to go beyond the engagement of the bourgeois elite and include plebeians as well as peasants as protagonists of history. I simply rejected the top-down, privileged or typical nationalist narration which ignores the majority struggling down below.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">I have clearly elaborated the reason for my “drastic change”, as you put it, in my essay “Decline of the Subaltern in Subaltern Studies” that appeared in </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">Writing Social History </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(1997) and, to a lesser extent, in “The Fascism of Sangh Parivar” in </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">Fascism: Essays on Europe and India </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(2016), edited by Jairus Banaji.
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">Why did you thoroughly reconstruct your old </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">Modern India</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9"> (1983) and write the new narrative</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9"> Modern Times: India 1880s–1950s: Environment, Economy and Culture?
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">30 years had rendered the work dated, and revising it seemed futile. My own historical perspective had also changed, prompting a new text. You yourself concentrate on creative expression. So, I think you will appreciate my chapters on “Languages and Literatures” as well as “Visual and Performing Arts”. Even the very title of the book carries a creative undertone which everyone will recognise. I borrowed the title from that evergreen film by Charlie Chaplin, </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">Modern Times </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9">(1936).
</lang>
</p>
<p style=".Bodylaser" ul="0" ol="0"  orgstyle="BODY 2025">
	<lang class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Bold" size="9">Subhoranjan Dasgupta</lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium" size="9"> </lang>
<lang  class="3" style=".Bodylaser" colour="#000000" orgstyle="BODY 2025" font="Antonia H1" fontStyle="Medium Italic" size="9">is an academic and author.</lang>
</p>

    </body.content>
  </body>
</nitf>