Dr Abu Jamil Faisel

is a public health expert.

SWAp has played a pivotal role in shaping Bangladesh’s health sector, improving coordination, ownership, and resource management. However, its limitations, including rigidity, donor dependency, and exclusion of key stakeholders, necessitate a reimagined approach.

Hybrid models, public-private partnerships, national health insurance schemes, and decentralised planning offer pathways to address these challenges. As Bangladesh works toward achieving universal health coverage and the health-related Sustainable Development Goals by 2030, a collaborative, inclusive, and forward-looking strategy will be essential.

Health system reform requires technical solutions, strong political will, and a commitment to equity and sustainability. While reform is essential, political will and strategic intent are critical in driving meaningful health sector reform. Bangladesh’s health system requires a clear focus on necessary and actionable reforms. The challenge lies in crafting precise recommendations and mobilising the political leadership needed to implement them effectively. Without sharp, actionable strategies, opportunities for impactful reform may be missed. It is essential to foster collaborative efforts across stakeholders to address systemic gaps and meet the health aspirations of the population.

Dr Abul Kalam Azad

is former director general of health services.

ABUL KALAM AZAD

The Sector Wide Approach (SWAp), introduced in Bangladesh in the late 1990s, sought to improve the health sector by uniting the efforts of government, donors, and NGOs under a unified national plan. The strategy proved effective in several areas—enhancing coordination, reducing duplication and ensuring more efficient use of resources. It fostered a government-led approach, empowering the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MOHFW) to take ownership of health programmes and make decisions that align with national priorities. The pooling of funds from various donors simplified financial management and allowed for a more harmonised implementation of health services. Moreover, SWAp contributed to capacity building by strengthening institutional frameworks, enhancing local expertise, and promoting evidence-based policymaking. However, SWAp also faced substantial challenges. Key stakeholders, such as the private sector and the Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and Co-operatives, were excluded from planning processes, limiting its scope and effectiveness. Centralised decision-making created bureaucratic delays, slowing programme implementation. Additionally, larger donors, such as the World Bank, exerted disproportionate influence, at times, prioritising global agendas over local needs. The risk of mismanagement also grew as pooled funding lacked adequate oversight and accountability mechanisms.

To address these shortcomings, I advocate transitioning to a new model, termed Sector-Wide Inclusive Planning and Evaluation (SWIPE) to integrate private sector actors, and decentralised planning and budgeting to the district level.

There is an urgent need for a comprehensive overhaul of Bangladesh’s health system. The existing dual-budget structure, which separates operating and development budgets, lacks coherence and prevents effective symbiosis between routine operational costs (staff salaries, fuel and utilities, repair and maintenance, travel, etc), and development costs for new infrastructure development and health service improvements.

The Health Population and Nutrition Sector Program (HPNSP) under SWAp brought advantages such as faster decision-making, delegation of authority to health managers, health workforce capacity building, improved coordination, monitoring and supervision. However, critical issues remain unresolved. Universal health coverage, elimination of healthcare discrimination, substantial improvements in healthcare quality, avoidance of verticalisation in healthcare delivery, and the reduction of out-of-pocket expenses continue to elude the system.

The fragmented and verticalised delivery of healthcare services limits integration and patient-centred care. Bangladesh’s age-old health systems have many inherent defects. The HPNSP or any similar prescription will not remedy it. Bangladesh urgently needs a serious and massive overhaul of its health systems in overall structure and processes to enable it effectively meeting the population’s health needs through integrated primary healthcare, sustainable universal health coverage, health sustainable development goals (SDGs), and client satisfaction.